I think all 3 are very very similar on the nail and in the bottle, but Essie- Merino Cool and Confetti- Moonstruck are the closest dupes out of the 3. Had I not polished my own fingers I wouldn't have been able to tell one from the other. Catrice- From Dusk To Dawn looks slightly different...a little more brown maybe? If you like any of these shades I would just get whichever formula, bottle, brush you like better...or whatever is cheaper and most accessible to you.
I have on 2 coats of each polish and 1 coat China Glaze Fast Forward
Index- Catrice From Dusk To Dawn, Middle- Essie Merino Cool, Ring- Confetti Moonstruck
Every brand now has at least one shade of mushroom, it seems, lol. I was going to get Merino Cool but prob have too many dupes of it already :)
ReplyDeleteOh, it's super kind of you. Thank You Jen. :)
ReplyDeleteI suppose I don't need Merino Cool since I get Moonstruck. ;)
Thank you. You just saved me some money.
ReplyDeleteI have Catrice - From Dusk to Dawn. I wanted Merino cool, but I think I'm not getting it :)
ReplyDeletePretties! I like your new layout. ;-)
ReplyDeleteJen, I added a link to this post on my post re:Channelesque as people have told me they think merino cool is a good dupe for the ChG!
ReplyDelete@Halifax- It does seem like that doesnt it?!? I kinda like it, I love this shade of polish so the more the merrier lol!
ReplyDelete@jellynat- you're welcome!
@L- woohoo for saving money!
@Lois- They are very close! You don't really need one if you have the other!
@MissMidnightBlue- thanks sweets! I like it too! I was getting bored of the old one
@Jess- Thanks girl! I think it's pretty close to Channelesque too, but I can't seem to find my bottle of that right now :( I'd bet $5 they are dupes!
They all do look very similar
ReplyDeleteJust wanted to thank you for taking the time to do this! I just found Confetti Moonstruck at CVS and plan to buy it because I love the Essie Merino Cool, but can't find it anywhere to buy locally and I don't want to pay shipping for nail polish! Thank you, thank you!!
ReplyDeletehow many nail polishes do u have
ReplyDeletea lot, not sure of the exact number though :)
ReplyDelete