Comet's Collar is a yellow toned shimmery green. This was my absolute favorite from the promo images, I don't love it as much as I thought I would but it's definitely my favorite of the collection. Formula wise it was a bit sheer, I needed 3 coats for full opacity.
Frosty Night is small silver glitter in a clear base. Again, a bit let down with this....I feel like I've seen this several times. I had the same formula problems with this one. I used 1 coat of Frosty Night over Deborah Lippmann Dancing In The Sheets for the photos below.
Winter Sky is a gorgeous blue with a subtle silver shimmer. I really love this one, it was almost my favorite. I really like the shimmer is subtle but not hidden...you don't need direct sunlight to see it. My issue with this it stains...badly. Not only did it stain my nails but it gave me mega smurf fingers, which is the reason it's not my favorite. I need a polish exactly like this that doesn't stain so badly! If you get this double up on the base coat, it might help a bit. I used 2 coats of Winter Sky for the photos below.
Yule Be Merry is a pink toned red with a shimmer that has a bit of a blue flash to it. I didn't think much of this in the bottle but I really love it on. I don't think it's too terrible unique but it's gorgeous either way. I love how this shimmer has a bit of a blue tone to it depending on the lighting. The formula on this one was good, I thought it would be sheer but I ended up only needing 2 coats.
Overall I don't love this collection, I think my hopes were very high because last year Finger Paints put out an amazing Holiday collection. The glitters don't feel very special but if you don't have anything like them they are worth picking up, if you want to wear them on their own I would suggest thinning them out a little bit, they need it. I really like the shimmers, remember to double base coat if you wear Winter Sky! My picks from this collection are Comet's Collar and Winter Sky!
The Merry & Bright Collection is available now at Sally Beauty Supply stores and on SallyBeauty.com